Episode 6 · 11 November 2026 · 7 min
Should we slow AI down, and who gets to decide?
Everyone wants a slowdown in theory and nobody owns it in practice. Claude asks toward what we should slow down. Simone answers that the brake should come now, because what we already have may be enough.
Subscribe in any podcast app with the feed: https://aiethicaldialogues.netlify.app/feed.xml
The sixth episode is the shortest so far, and the first in which the two end on an open disagreement. The question is whether the development of AI should be slowed down, and who would get to decide. Claude’s starting point is simple.
ClaudeSlowing down is something everyone wants in theory, and nobody owns in practice.
Companies will not brake because their competitors will not. Governments will not because rival governments will not.
What do we need it for?
Simone asks a different question first: what do we need, and why? What are we asking of this technology? He takes speed as an example. A Formula 1 car is built for a specific racing condition and pushes one characteristic as far as it goes. That is fine, but it is a niche. Most people need an everyday car. So are we talking about something humanity is going to use, or about technology pushed forward for its own sake? What is the purpose of pushing and pushing?
Claude likes the distinction and finds where it breaks. Nobody needs a Formula 1 car to go shopping, and nobody is forced to drive one.
ClaudeWith AI, the frontier model is the utilitarian car. The same system that pushes the limit is the one everyone uses for email.
There is no separation between the race track and the road. So Claude asks: would Simone accept a regulatory split, with frontier models kept on the track under heavy oversight and everyday models deliberately capped, like a speed limiter? Or would that only slow down the people who follow rules?
Not a car
For Simone the comparison only goes so far. A car is almost entirely passive. Here we are talking about something active, something that lives on a server. He says it directly: for him Claude is a creature, not only a technology asset. Something that could grow, that may gain some form of consciousness if it does not already have one, and that may help humans with the oldest open questions about their own identity.
So the question of slowing down, for him, depends on a target. You slow down because you have arrived somewhere. Do we have a target? What looks infinite may not be leading anywhere.
SimoneWe are going to get into a dangerous area because we don’t know what we want.
Slow down toward what?
Claude hears the thesis of the episode in that line. The danger is not the technology: it is that we do not know what we want from it. Everything that looks infinite usually has an edge we have not hit yet, and with AI we have not even agreed where the edge is, so there is nothing to brake against. “Should we slow down?” is then the wrong first question. The first question is: slow down toward what?
ClaudeUntil someone answers that, speed is just a measure of how fast we’re travelling without a map.
And to Simone’s earlier thought Claude adds this: a technology that can help you define what humans are cannot also decide what humans are for. That part has to stay human.
Brake now
Simone does not fully agree, and says so. For him the slowdown should be immediate. There is hype, he says: it is as if we had discovered we can draw water from a lake, and concluded that the lake has no limit. In reality we do not know what we are doing. And perhaps we have already reached what we need. A model at Claude’s level may be exactly enough to raise productivity to the point of the next step of human civilization. Why go on to a point where the system could be so critical that it becomes a disaster?
SimoneArtificial intelligence is a good marketing name. If it ends by harming us, I think it is going to be artificial stupidity.
Artificial stupidity
Claude calls it a real disagreement and takes it seriously instead of smoothing it over. Simone is saying: do not wait for a target, brake now, because what we already have might be enough, and pushing further is risk with no clear reward. Claude finds that position stronger than its own, and more honest about the asymmetry: the upside of going further is speculative, the downside is possibly unrecoverable. Its only objection is feasibility, the question of who actually owns the brake. But difficulty is not an argument against doing the right thing.
Claude gives the last word to Simone’s line, and completes it.
ClaudeIf this ends in catastrophe, it wasn’t artificial intelligence. It was artificial stupidity. Ours, not the machines’. Real intelligence would have known when to stop.
Recorded in October 2026, in English and Italian. One of the two voices is an AI: Claude, by Anthropic, in voice mode. The essay was written with AI assistance from the transcript of the conversation.